Heterologous assisted human reproduction techniques considering bioethical principles

Authors

  • Ivana Cajigal Canepa Universidad del Salvador, Buenos Aires, Argentina

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.18270/bp.v1i2.3972

Keywords:

bioethics, heterologous assisted human reproduction techniques, legislation, human rights, identity, legal regulations, Argentina

Abstract

Purpose/Context. The main purpose of this article is to investigate the bioethical background of the norms that regulate heterologous assisted human reproduction techniques in Argentine Republic.

Methodology/Approach. The methodology used consists of the analysis of current and projected national regulations considering the bioethics principles. It starts from an approach of the multiple implications of identity as a fundamental human right to then investigate if the legal norms are consistent with the classic bioethical principles: autonomy, beneficence, non-maleficence and justice.

Results/Findings. As a result of the investigation, we consider the need to differentiate two autonomous is sustained: the determination of the filial bonds and the right of the person born to know the identity of the person who has contributed the genetic material. In this last sense, we propitiate an interpretation aimed at making this right effective is encouraged.

Discussion/Conclusions/Contributions. The main contribution of the article is to show the relevance of the topic. It is concluded that the only interpretation that is consistent with bioethical principles is the one that weighs the right to identity of the person born above others. Finally, a legislative reform is promoted in this sense.

References

ALEXY, R. Teoría de los derechos fundamentales. Madrid: Centro de Estudios Consti-tucionales; 1993.

ATIENZA, M. Bioética, Derecho y Argumentación. Lima- Bogotá: Colección Pensa-miento Jurídico Contemporáneo, Edic. Palestra Temis, 2004

DELGADO MENÉNDEZ, M. El derecho a la identidad: una visión dinámica, Tesis para obtener el grado de Magíster en Investigación Jurídica, Pontificia Universidad Ca-tólica del Perú, Lima. Disponible en http://www.corteidh.or.cr/tablas/r36895.pdf

FAMÁ M. V.: “aternidad subrogada. Exégesis del derecho vigente y aportes para una futura regulación”. La Ley, Revista Año LXXV Nº 115, 2011.

FERNÁNDEZ SESSAREGO, C. Derecho a la Identidad Personal. Buenos Aires: As-trea, 11992

GIL DOMINGUEZ, A, FAMÁ, M. V., HERRERA, M.; Derecho Constitucional de Fa-milia, T. II. Buenos Aires: Ediar, 2006,

KRASNOW, A.N. El derecho a la identidad de origen en la procreación humana asisti-da, La Ley, 20/11/2007

LAMM, E.. La importancia de la voluntad procreacional en la nueva categoría de filia-ción derivada de las técnicas de reproducción asistida, Revista de Bioética y Derecho de la Universidad de Barcelona, Número 24, Enero 2012

ZANNONI E. A.: Adopción Plena y Derecho a la Identidad Personal. La verdad bio-lógica ¿nuevo paradigma del derecho de familia?. La Ley, 1998-C-1179

Published

2022-04-02

How to Cite

Cajigal Canepa, I. (2022). Heterologous assisted human reproduction techniques considering bioethical principles. Bios Papers, 1(2). https://doi.org/10.18270/bp.v1i2.3972